In reviewing the available memory allocators, none of their strategies could be used without some modification. The kernel memory allocator that we ended up with is a hybrid of the fast memory allocator found in the 4.2BSD C library and a slower but more-memory-efficient first-fit allocator.
Small allocations are done using the 4.2BSD power-of-two list strategy; the typical allocation requires only a computation of the list to use and the removal of an element if it is available, so it is quite fast. Macros are provided to avoid the cost of a subroutine call. Only if the request cannot be fulfilled from a list is a call made to the allocator itself. To ensure that the allocator is always called for large requests, the lists corresponding to large allocations are always empty. Appendix A shows the data structures and implementation of the macros.
Similarly, freeing a block of memory can be done with a macro. The macro computes the list on which to place the request and puts it there. The free routine is called only if the block of memory is considered to be a large allocation. Including the cost of blocking out interrupts, the allocation and freeing macros generate respectively only nine and sixteen (simple) VAX instructions.
Because of the inefficiency of power-of-two allocation strategies for large allocations, a different strategy is used for allocations larger than two kilobytes. The selection of two kilobytes is derived from our statistics on the utilization of memory within the kernel, that showed that 95 to 98% of allocations are of size one kilobyte or less. A frequent caller of the memory allocator (the name translation function) always requests a one kilobyte block. Additionally the allocation method for large blocks is based on allocating pieces of memory in multiples of pages. Consequently the actual allocation size for requests of size or less are identical.** In 4.3BSD on the VAX, the (software) page size is one kilobyte, so two kilobytes is the smallest logical cutoff.
Large allocations are first rounded up to be a multiple of the page size. The allocator then uses a first-fit algorithm to find space in the kernel address arena set aside for dynamic allocations. Thus a request for a five kilobyte piece of memory will use exactly five pages of memory rather than eight kilobytes as with the power-of-two allocation strategy. When a large piece of memory is freed, the memory pages are returned to the free memory pool, and the address space is returned to the kernel address arena where it is coalesced with adjacent free pieces.
Another technique to improve both the efficiency of memory utilization and the speed of allocation is to cluster same-sized small allocations on a page. When a list for a power-of-two allocation is empty, a new page is allocated and divided into pieces of the needed size. This strategy speeds future allocations as several pieces of memory become available as a result of the call into the allocator.
.in 0 .ce .
The allocator can be called both from the top half of the kernel, which is willing to wait for memory to become available, and from the interrupt routines in the bottom half of the kernel that cannot wait for memory to become available. Clients indicate their willingness (and ability) to wait with a flag to the allocation routine. For clients that are willing to wait, the allocator guarrentees that their request will succeed. Thus, these clients can need not check the return value from the allocator. If memory is unavailable and the client cannot wait, the allocator returns a null pointer. These clients must be prepared to cope with this (hopefully infrequent) condition (usually by giving up and hoping to do better later).